Requirement for a web-app-worldmonitor role: the upstream four-service
stack (dashboard, AIS relay, Redis, REST proxy) behind the platform's
Keycloak login through oauth2-proxy, in compose and in swarm.
It records what the upstream self-hosted mode offers and lacks, eleven
proposed decisions the operator has to confirm before implementation,
the target role layout and the acceptance criteria.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
One conflict, in the generated role overview table of README.md.
Both sides had edited the same block. Upstream dropped Redis from the pihole
row; this branch still listed it. Upstream also listed svc-net-wireguard-core,
-plain and -firewalled, which this branch removed in e706170a0b as superseded
by the unified svc-net-wireguard role.
Resolved by taking upstream's block and then running `make readme-index`, so
the table is generated from the roles that actually exist rather than
hand-merged: Redis is gone from pihole, the three legacy WireGuard roles stay
gone, and svc-net-wireguard is listed once. `make readme-index check=true`
reports the table up to date.
Git kept the role deletions silently and correctly - upstream has not touched
those three directories since the merge base, so there was no modify/delete
conflict to resolve.
Nobody could sign in to Odoo through Keycloak. Odoo sent an http redirect
URI, and Keycloak refused it as "Invalid parameter: redirect_uri".
The addon auth_oauth_https builds that URI from web.base.url. Two things
kept it from doing so after the image moved to Odoo 20.
Its manifest declared version 19.0.1.8.0, and Odoo marks a module whose
version names another series as not installable. It only warns about that,
so the install task stayed green and the addon was missing. The manifest
now declares 1.8.0, which Odoo prefixes with its own series.
Once installed, the addon read the parameter with get_param, which Odoo 20
replaced by typed getters. The call raised AttributeError, a broad except
logged it and fell back to the URL of the request, which is http behind
the proxy. The addon reads the parameter with get_str now and no longer
catches the error.
A deploy now fails when the addon is not installed afterwards. The check
reads ir_module_module, because the output of "odoo -i" does not tell an
installed module from a skipped one.
The spec logged out by navigating to /web/session/logout. Odoo 20 accepts
POST only on that route and answered 405, so both SSO tests failed after
a successful login. The spec logs out through the user menu now.
A host that runs the suite with several workers still failed it. Odoo
computes the session token of an account from its OAuth access token, so
every new sign-in ends the other sessions of that account, and the spec
files share the administrator. The role caps its suite at one worker
with PLAYWRIGHT_MAX_WORKERS, which the central config now honours, and
the spec asserts the cap.
Closes#822
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Seven real, branch-caused failures surfaced after rebasing onto main
(v14.0.0, ~900 commits):
- opensearch_dashboards_yml volume: type: config -> type: secret
(renders a live OIDC client secret; was world-readable at 0444 in a
volume type the platform treats as non-sensitive, same fix pattern
as web-app-gitlab's rails_secrets_yml)
- meta/networks.yml: local.subnet collided with web-app-litellm
- meta/services.yml: indexer/console ports collided with
svc-ai-litellm and web-app-openclaw (both added during the gap)
- compose.yml.j2: healthcheck interval/timeout/start_period now go
through the SPOT lookup instead of hardcoded values
- README.md: regenerated Quick Setup section, fixed credits link
formatting
- docs/requirements/035-mcp-proxy-expansion.md: added web-app-wazuh
to the adapter_candidate list (has a real, currently-unpublished
API surface - manager :55000, indexer :9200 - not yet evaluated
for an MCP adapter, same bucket web-app-checkmk/prometheus sat in
before promotion)
Two regressions caught by re-verification and fixed in the same pass:
meta/services.yml briefly reached into a role var directly (fixed to
use the lookup('config', ...) pattern already used elsewhere), and the
credits-link fix dropped required bold markdown.
Remaining test failures after this fix are confirmed pre-existing and
unrelated: svc-net-tor's nftables guard rule (kernel EOPNOTSUPP), an
INFINITO_SWARM_STEP_TIMEOUT_MINUTES Makefile/default.env drift, and a
CI chunk-budget drift.
Renames the mesh-only first pass to the prologue it always was, since
PASS 1 and PASS 2 now both name application deploys, and states why the
credential reset cannot move to the direct arm's slot.
The update bot opened a version PR for web-app-jira (#821) although the role is end of life: none of the updaters looked at the lifecycle. utils.update.base.is_maintained now answers that question once, and the collectors for image versions, declared version sources, pip pins, repository refs and the addon check skip a role whose lifecycle is eol.
The lint that requires every semver pin to be watched shares that scope, otherwise it would report the pins of the eol roles as unwatched. Every other stage, deprecated included, stays in the update scope.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Narrowing the meshed drill to its backup half bought budget by giving
up the recovery legs over the mesh. The budget overrun is worth measuring
before it is designed around, so the pre-drill pass and the full teardown and
recover come back. Reverts a27b093c4.
No conflicts. Two files were touched by both sides and both kept each
side: the Makefile, where upstream retires the mcp-audit target and this
branch pins the throwaway cluster's vpn axis, and requirement 035, where
the role table keeps the single svc-net-wireguard row.
Incoming carries the fixes for two applications this branch's last run
failed on -- penpot probing its frontend without curl, and mobilizon's
postgres 18 migrations -- plus dependency bumps and a lint repair.
Gates on the merged tree: unit 6202, lint 523, integration 330,
ansible-lint clean.
The version-source updater only read meta/services.yml. An addon pinned in
meta/addons/<id>.yml stayed where it was: the ONLYOFFICE connector for
Nextcloud sat on v10.1.2, which does not install on Nextcloud 35, until
someone bumped it by hand.
The updater now reads addon files too. An addon declares its source in the
`update:` block it already has, beside monitored, catalog and upstream_id.
A monitored addon of the github-releases catalog needs nothing more: its
upstream_id names the repository whose tags are its versions. The
update-version-sources job opens the PRs, one per role.
Every pinned addon is wired:
- nextcloud onlyoffice carries its own version pin now. Its archive URL
stays a literal that carries the pin, because
test_pinned_addon_archives_available reads it as written
- wordpress mcp-adapter, moodle auth_oidc and jellyfin sso-authentication
follow the tags of their repository, moodle within its v4.5 series
- the three xwiki extensions read their Maven metadata
- pretix-oidc reads the PyPI simple index. The JSON API answers 404 behind
the package cache the test stack routes pypi.org through
- joomla's plugin is built here and jellyfin's ldap-authentication is bound
to the md5 of its archive; both are opted out with that reason
A bump rewrites the pin and the config.archive line together, and an
archive that does not carry the pin fails test_version_keys, so the two
cannot drift apart again. test_version_pins_are_watched covers addon pins
as well: a new one without a source or a reasoned opt-out fails the lint.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The Docker updater watches image plus version, the repository updater
repository plus ref. A dozen pins fell outside both - an app_version, a
release, a tag in a registry neither speaks - so nothing ever told anyone
they had gone stale.
Such a pin now names its upstream next to itself in an `update:` block:
git_tags, registry_tags, npm, http_regex or a role-local script, with
`match` selecting a tag flavour and `strip` removing a prefix the pin does
not carry. utils/update/source.py resolves them beside the two existing
updaters, `python -m cli.contributing.update.source` bumps them, the
update-version-sources job opens one PR per role, and
tests/external/update/source warns while a bump is pending.
Two lints hold the rule: every semver pin is watched by one of the three
updaters or opted out with a reason, and a semver only ever sits behind
`version`, `<what>_version` or `ref` - which renames moodle's release to
app_version and simpleicons' local_version to local_tag, the latter being
the tag of a locally built image rather than an upstream version. A
declaration naming a key the entity does not carry, or a type the resolver
does not know, fails the lint instead of resolving nothing in silence.
Picked from feature/store-i18n (94d607fd0a) onto current main. Two things
differ from the original: svc-ai-lmstudio no longer carries an app_version
pin, so its declaration is dropped, and web-app-stalwart's webui_version,
added since, declares the git tags of the webui repository.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The report aggregated each role's meta/mcp.yml into one table, and its
freshness test failed on every image-version bump of an MCP-serving role,
because the updater edits services.yml and nothing regenerates the committed
report. The table added nothing the sources lack: scope and credential subject
were identical for every role, so it restated its inputs.
The generator, the report, its freshness test, make mcp-audit and the i8mcau
alias go, and make docs no longer calls the generator. The metadata stays in
each role's meta/mcp.yml, where test_mcp_schema.py enforces its shape, and
requirement 035 now says so. The classification and completeness lints stay,
because they check the lists in 035 against the roles, not the report.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
No conflicts, and no file touched by both sides. Incoming is a run of
Docker image version bumps plus one CI change, which moves the diff
baseline from a force-pushed mirror of main to a fetch in each consumer --
entry-push-latest.yml and the resolve scripts, none of which this branch
touches.
Gates on the merged tree: unit 6199, lint 525, integration 330, external
19, ansible-lint clean, markdownlint clean, ruff clean.
Why a meshed round deploys twice when a drill is coming and once when it
is not, why the end-to-end suites belong to the pass after the drill, and
why the condition is asked of the drill rather than decided again.
test_the_committed_report_is_freshly_generated compares the committed
table against a fresh render. The image updater edits only
meta/services.yml, so the pretix row still read 2026.7.0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
test_the_committed_report_is_freshly_generated compares the committed
table against a fresh render. The image updater edits only
meta/services.yml, so the mattermost row still read 11.11.0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
test_the_committed_report_is_freshly_generated compares the committed
table against a fresh render. The image updater edits only
meta/services.yml, so the gitea row still read 1.27.3.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
test_the_committed_report_is_freshly_generated compares the committed
table against a fresh render. The image updater edits only
meta/services.yml, so the checkmk row still read 2.4.0p32.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
test_the_committed_report_is_freshly_generated compares the committed
table against a fresh render. The image updater edits only
meta/services.yml, so the baserow row still read 2.3.4.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
One conflict, in the generated role table of README.md. Both sides changed
the same rows: upstream swapped WordPress's Mailu dependency for Stalwart,
while this branch replaced the three svc-net-wireguard-{core,plain,
firewalled} rows with the single svc-net-wireguard it deploys.
Resolved by regenerating rather than by hand, since make readme-index owns
that table and gates it with --check. The regenerated table carries both
sides and the check reports it up to date.
README.md was the only file both sides touched, and nothing in the tree
still names the three replaced roles.
lifecycle.md said a deprecated role is still covered by the test suite while the tested envelope already left it out. A deprecated role is now untested: the matrix-deploy MUST NOT exercise it and a failure in it MUST NOT block a release, while planned, pre-alpha and eol stay open to best-effort runs. The complexity legend says untested too.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
layout.md listed six of the nine lifecycle stages the layout lint accepts and left out rc, maintenance and eol. It now defers to the stages in lifecycle.md, which already define every value, deprecated included, with its criteria.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
entry-push-latest.yml lets a push to main cancel the running pipeline only when its head commit starts with the release subject pkgmgr writes. The new integration test reads that prefix from the workflow and the tag schema from scripts/github/resolve/release/tag.sh, then requires every release tag from v13.0.0 on to sit on "Release version X.Y.Z". Six tags between v10.1.0 and v11.6.0 carry "Release X.Y.Z", so the check starts at the first tag of the uniform run.
call-test.yml now checks out with full history and tags, the pair detect-release already relies on; a depth-1 checkout carries no tags and would skip the test. Forks and tagless clones skip it on purpose.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
A push to main whose head commit starts with "Release version " (the subject pkgmgr writes for every release) now cancels the main run in progress, so the release starts at once instead of queueing behind it. Every other push to main still leaves the running pipeline alone.
When the pushed main commit carries a vX.Y.Z tag, the orchestrator runs with chunk_gate false: every chunk deploys and reports, and a failed chunk still turns the run red, so release-guard and release-version stay skipped.
entry-cancel-superseded.yml mirrors the new rule behind its push guard, parenthesised so && does not bind the release clause; the mirror test composes the expected rule the same way.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
One conflict, in the MCP exclusion list of requirement 035. Both sides
edited the same line: main added svc-net-tor-smtp, this branch replaced the
three svc-net-wireguard-{core,plain,firewalled} entries with the single
svc-net-wireguard it deploys. Resolved to the union of both — 24 entries —
which is what the merged tree actually holds.
Everything else merged clean and was checked for overlap rather than
assumed: no reference anywhere still names the three replaced roles;
matrix.py kept main's PRIMARY_APPS alongside the reordered round, and the
bootstrap pass does not need it, since only one template reads it and
group_vars defaults it empty; and main's ansible.cfg addition sits in
[defaults], so the ssh_args the mesh tool derives its own connection
settings from are untouched.
Why the first pass stops at the mesh, and what the meshed row therefore
stops covering: the second deploy itself, so no re-run proving a redeploy
changes nothing, and no async update pass. Every direct-transport row still
deploys twice, so that coverage moves across the axis rather than
disappearing.
The offset came from the spoke's position in a sorted list, so a host that
sorts earlier renumbered every member behind it. `wg syncconf` carries keys
and peers onto a live interface and never its address, so a renumbered member
keeps answering on the old address while the peers and the inventory have
moved to the new one -- and the address it gave up can be handed to a new
member while the old owner still holds it.
The planner now reuses the addresses already on disk and allocates only an
unseen member, from the lowest free offset. A value outside the subnet, a
duplicate, and the hub's own offset are refused, so a mirrored host_vars
cannot hand a spoke the hub's address. Rotation keeps addresses: it replaces
identities, not addresses.
The routing assertions re-planned the mesh and compared the result with
itself, so a writer that stored the mesh subnet in place of the routed range
would have passed; they now read the entry off disk, which is what the role
reads.
7ed60e1fc2 renamed the Assumption 10 heading in security.md, and the
link in sandbox.md still used the short #assumption-10 fragment, which
no heading slug matches. It now carries the full slug of the new
heading, the form 4efa892706 on feature/store-i18n uses for the old
one, so that branch's merge resolves the line by keeping main's side.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
An external report flagged the Bash(*) allow in the committed
.claude/settings.json. Bash(*) stays: every command still runs inside
the OS sandbox, and deny and ask take precedence over it. Reviewing the
file against its own documentation turned up two real gaps instead.
security.md and settings.md cite an rm -rf* deny rule as the guard
against `rm -rf .` wiping the worktree and .git/, but the rule was lost
in ee30f6d446 when the deny list was rewritten. It is back.
denyRead covered ~/.aws, ~/.config/gcloud, ~/.gnupg and ~/.kube only.
~/.docker/config.json holds registry logins inline, ~/.git-credentials
and ~/.netrc hold plaintext credentials, and the default ~/.ssh/id_*
keys were readable because Assumption 10 kept ~/.ssh open for an
ask-gated git push that has since moved to deny. All nine paths are
denied now. The rest of ~/.ssh stays readable, so SSH fetches keep
known_hosts and authenticate through the agent socket. Sandboxed docker
calls pull anonymously and print a config warning on stderr.
Thanks to Hanno Horrmeyer for the report.
Reported-by: Hanno Horrmeyer
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Records why the nodes converge before the controller joins, and reopens the
key-rotation criterion: the rotation did sever the run, so the box was ticked
on an assumption rather than on evidence.
The controller is now a mesh member rather than staying off it behind a
gateway hop, and the two-phase seam falls between the two deploy passes the
round already had, so the second runs over the tunnel at no extra CI cost.
The gate and the axis are separated: whether a swarm deploy carries the mesh
is decided per run, and when it does the mesh is mandatory. Swarm and the mesh
are independent, so an off run omits the role entirely and proves swarm still
works with no mesh logic in the path.
The MTU is measured rather than declared. Criteria follow: three new ones for
the transport, two for the axis arms, one for the tooling, and the MTU one is
unchecked again because what it claimed has changed.
Brings in 225 commits, including the merged web-app-openbao work and the
LMStudio loopback fix.
Seven conflicts:
- The legacy svc-net-wireguard-core/plain/firewalled roles this branch deleted
in e706170a0 were modified upstream. The deletion stands, which is the whole
premise of the branch.
- The MCP audit takes upstream's list plus svc-net-firewall, with the three
legacy wireguard entries collapsed into the single svc-net-wireguard: 23.
- web-app-openbao/README.md takes main's reviewed version wholesale.
- matrix.py takes both sides: upstream's app_id argument to _reset_credentials
and this branch's _write_mesh call after it.
The merge pushed matrix.py to 511 lines against the 500 cap, so the step
runner moved to utils/tests/swarm/run.py, which is self-contained and leaves
matrix.py at 427. Its test moved with it.
An agent cannot see whether the operator committed on top of its last
commit in the meantime. An amend then rewrites a commit it never
authored: it happened to a signed, tagged release commit, which only a
soft reset onto the original recovered. Follow-up changes land as a new
commit instead.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Brings in the LMStudio loopback fix (LMS_SERVER_HOST=0.0.0.0 plus the
readiness probe changes), which is what failed the LiteLLM model warm and took
Matrix, Mattermost, Moodle, XWiki and Zammad down with it on the last run.
Also folds CLAUDE.md and GEMINI.md into AGENTS.md, and carries upstream's own
regeneration of the MCP audit report, which matches ours.
No conflicts.
CLAUDE.md and GEMINI.md existed as per-runtime extensions of AGENTS.md, and
only one of them carried anything at all: GEMINI.md stated that it had no
additions, while CLAUDE.md held rules that bind every runtime anyway — the
permission announcement, the make-over-raw preference, the loop, chain and
heredoc bans, the stream-the-log-to-/tmp rule, the CI-evidence rule, the push
ban and the comment rule. A rule that binds every agent does not belong in one
agent's file. AGENTS.md absorbs them and now states that no tool-specific
extension file exists; agents whose runtime auto-loads a different filename
reach it through their own configuration instead.
The filenames were machinery as much as prose. The PR templates, the branch
and pull-request scope tables, the settings and security docs that justified
the loop deny by "the textual CLAUDE.md rule", six requirement documents whose
push instruction linked ../../CLAUDE.md, and a test docstring citing the
shell-loop ban all named them, and now name AGENTS.md.
scripts/meta/resolve/pr/scope.sh deliberately keeps matching CLAUDE.md and
GEMINI.md: this change deletes them, and without those patterns the change
itself would not classify as agent-scope.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
