Introduce a single grammar for per-line, per-block, and per-file
suppression markers across the test suite, replacing seven ad-hoc
syntaxes that had drifted apart.
Helper
utils/annotations/suppress.py exposes is_suppressed_at,
is_suppressed_in_head, is_suppressed_anywhere, line_has_rule, and
suppressed_line_numbers. Markers may use either `noqa` or `nocheck`
(case-insensitive synonyms), live inside `#`, `//`, `{# ... #}`, or
`<\!-- ... -->` comments, and combine multiple kebab-case rules
comma-separated. 17 unit tests cover the grammar in isolation.
Refactored consumers
- tests/external/repository/test_urls_reachable.py (rule: url)
- tests/external/docker/test_image_versions.py via
utils/docker/version_updater.py (rule: docker-version)
- tests/lint/repository/test_no_direct_yaml_calls.py (rule:
direct-yaml)
- tests/lint/ansible/test_service_shared_consistency.py (rule:
shared)
- tests/lint/ansible/roles/test_web_app_email_integration.py (rule:
email)
- tests/lint/repository/test_python_file_size.py (rule: file-size)
- tests/lint/ansible/test_run_once_tags.py +
tests/integration/roles/run_once/test_schema.py (rules: run-once,
run-once-suffix)
Marker migration
12 role tasks/main.yml files: `# run_once_<key>: deactivated`
-> `# nocheck: run-once`. roles/web-app-suitecrm/meta/services.yml
drops a malformed inline `noqa: intentional legacy pin` from a TODO
comment so the new parser does not pick it up as a stray rule.
Caching wins
Test files that previously loaded YAML / read files via raw
yaml.safe_load + Path.read_text now route through utils.cache.yaml
(load_yaml_any / load_yaml_str) and utils.cache.files.read_text:
- test_service_shared_consistency.py
- test_web_app_email_integration.py
- tests/integration/roles/run_once/test_schema.py
- utils/docker/version_updater.py
This both speeds up repeated reads and stays consistent with the
direct-yaml lint policy.
Documentation
New SPOT page at docs/contributing/actions/testing/suppression.md
with grammar, position semantics, the catalog of rules, examples,
and an "adding a new rule" checklist. lint.md and external.md drop
their per-rule tables and link to the new page. All touched docs
conform to docs/contributing/documentation.md (no em-dash thought
breaks, no SPOT self-labels, RFC-2119 keywords used consistently).
Settings sort tooling
scripts/lint/sort_claude_settings.sh wraps utils/claude/settings_sort.py
and is wired into scripts/lint/autoformat.sh. The tooling fixes the
ASCII-ascending requirement enforced by
tests/lint/repository/test_claude_settings_sorted.py; the test's
failure message now points operators at the script. .claude/settings.json
is committed in sorted form.
New lint guard
==============
tests/lint/repository/test_no_direct_yaml_calls.py AST-walks the
production tree (utils/, cli/, plugins/, filter_plugins/,
lookup_plugins/, roles/, scripts/, tasks/) and flags any direct
`yaml.safe_load` / `yaml.safe_dump` / `yaml.load` / `yaml.dump` /
`yaml.safe_load_all` / `yaml.dump_all` call. Aliased imports are
tracked: `import yaml as Y` ⇒ `Y.safe_load(...)` is flagged;
`from yaml import safe_load` ⇒ bare `safe_load(...)` is flagged.
Per-line opt-out: `# noqa: direct-yaml` on the call's physical line
(or any line spanned by a multi-line call). No central exemption
list — every legitimate exception lives next to its call with a
human-readable rationale in the surrounding comment.
Cache module additions
======================
* `dump_yaml_str(data)` — symmetric to `safe_dump(data)` with no file
path. Used for stdout output and filter return values where the
cache cannot help but the API needs to stay consistent.
* `load_yaml_str(text)` — symmetric to `safe_load(text)`. Used when
YAML comes from an HTTP body, a mutated buffer, or a mock-patched
source whose content does not correspond to a stable on-disk file.
Migrated production call sites (33 → 0 direct-yaml violations)
==============================================================
* utils/{entity_name_utils, valid_deploy_id, invokable, service_registry,
domains/list, applications/{config, in_group_deps},
docker/image/discovery, meta/{port_bands, scan},
roles/{dependency_resolver, meta_lookup, resource_validation}}
* cli/{build/{graph, inventory/full/command}, create/inventory/{host_vars,
mirror_overrides}, fix/vars_main_files, meta/{applications/in_group_deps,
callorder}, mirror/resolver, validate/inventory}
* plugins/{filter/{compose_volumes, get_all_application_ids, get_role,
invokable_paths, role_path_by_app_id}, lookup/applications_current_play}
* roles/{svc-db-postgres/filter_plugins/split_postgres_connections,
web-app-bigbluebutton/filter_plugins/compose_mods,
web-app-dashboard/lookup_plugins/docker_cards}
Behaviour adjustments
=====================
* utils/roles/dependency_resolver — `safe_load_all` (multi-doc) →
single-doc `load_yaml_any` wrapped in a list. Ansible task files are
single-doc by convention; the downstream multi-doc loop stays intact
for forward compatibility.
* roles/sys-svc-compose-ca/files/compose_ca.py — KEEPS direct
yaml.safe_load / yaml.safe_dump (annotated with noqa). The script is
copied to the target host via `ansible.builtin.copy` and the target
has no `utils/` package on PYTHONPATH.
noqa-annotated direct-yaml call sites (with rationale)
======================================================
* utils/cache/yaml.py — IS the cache; would recurse.
* utils/handler/yaml.py — vault-aware Loader subclass that wraps
\!vault scalars in VaultScalar; cache-by-path collapses the wrapping.
* cli/encrypt/inventory/__main__.py — vault-aware Dumper subclass that
emits \!vault literal blocks; the cached dump_yaml writes plain YAML
which is the wrong output here.
* roles/sys-svc-compose-ca/files/compose_ca.py — runtime-deployed.
* tasks/utils/migrate_meta_layout.py — once-off migration script.
Validation
==========
* Unit tests: 1573 passed.
* Lint: 56 passed (incl. new test_no_direct_yaml_calls).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Single atomic landing for three back-to-back role-meta refactor requirements
(see docs/requirements/008-role-meta-layout.md, 009-per-role-networks-and-ports.md,
010-role-meta-runafter-lifecycle-migration.md).
req-008 — role meta layout
* Move every role's metadata under meta/<topic>.yml with file-root
convention (no wrapping key matching the basename):
- schema/main.yml + config/main.yml.credentials → meta/schema.yml
- users/main.yml → meta/users.yml
- config/main.yml.server → meta/server.yml
- config/main.yml.rbac → meta/rbac.yml
- config/main.yml.compose.services + every other top-level key
of config/main.yml inlined under <entity>.<key>
→ meta/services.yml
- config/main.yml.compose.volumes → meta/volumes.yml
* Drop the legacy schema/, users/, config/ directories from every role.
* meta/schema.yml: support nested credential keys, optional `default:`
field (Jinja literal, not rendered/validated/regenerated), implicit
`algorithm: plain`.
* Materialised paths drop the `compose.` prefix:
compose.services.<e>.<…> → services.<e>.<…>
compose.volumes.<k> → volumes.<k>
<former-top-level>.<…> → services.<entity_name>.<former-top-level>.<…>
* Update every Python consumer (utils/cache, utils/manager, utils/applications,
plugins/lookup, plugins/filter, cli/*) plus every Jinja template, vars/*.yml
and task file to the new paths.
* No legacy fallback. Repository-wide grep for `compose.services.` /
`compose.volumes.` / `schema/main.yml` / `users/main.yml` / `config/main.yml`
is empty outside docs/requirements/ and tasks/utils/migrate_meta_layout.py.
* Add tests/lint/repository/test_role_meta_layout.py guarding against the
old paths returning, and an explicit lint guard that meta/variants.yml
files do not carry a `compose:` wrapper.
req-009 — per-role networks/ports
* Move group_vars/all/08_networks.yml.defaults_networks.local.<role>.{subnet,
dns_resolver} into roles/<role>/meta/server.yml.networks.local.{subnet,
dns_resolver}.
* Delete group_vars/all/09_ports.yml entirely; ports now live on the
service entity that exposes them at
roles/<role>/meta/services.yml.<entity>.ports.{inter,local,public}.
* Rename + int-cast every former top-level `services.<entity>.port`
field to `services.<entity>.ports.inter` (single int).
* Always-category-keyed maps for ports.local / ports.public; relay
spans use {start, end} integers.
* Add PORT_BANDS map to group_vars/all/08_networks.yml — single source
of truth for the per-<scope>.<category> band ranges, consumed by both
the new CLI helpers and the lint test.
* New CLI helpers (cli meta ports suggest, cli meta networks suggest)
walk the live role tree gap-first then increment-fallback, with
deterministic output and non-zero exit on capacity overflow.
* cli create role consumes both helpers when scaffolding a new role.
* Lint extensions: bare-int port shape rejection, host-bound port
collision check (single ints + relay span integers, inter excluded),
band-membership check with documented allow-list for the legacy
web-app-bigbluebutton.bigbluebutton.local.http: 48087 entry.
req-010 — run_after / lifecycle migration
* Move galaxy_info.run_after and galaxy_info.lifecycle out of
meta/main.yml into meta/services.yml.<primary_entity>.{run_after,
lifecycle}; <primary_entity> is the value returned by
get_entity_name(role_name).
* For multi-entity roles whose primary entity has no compose service
(web-app-bluesky → bluesky, web-app-matrix → matrix, desk/dev/drv/
gen roles), create a dedicated metadata-only top-level entry under
<primary_entity>.
* Introduce utils/roles/meta_lookup.py with get_role_run_after /
get_role_lifecycle that resolve <primary_entity> once and read from
meta/services.yml; degrade gracefully when meta/services.yml is
absent OR the field is absent; raise MetaServicesShapeError when the
file exists but is malformed.
* Update every consumer (utils/service_registry, utils/invokable,
cli/meta/applications/resolution/run_after/__main__, cli/meta/roles/
lifecycle_filter/__main__, cli/meta/applications/resolution/combined,
cli/build/{tree,graph,role_include}, cli/deploy/development/{common,
init,deps,deploy}, plugins/filter/canonical_domains_map, etc.) to
use the helper.
* Lint guards: no run_after/lifecycle in meta/main.yml; lifecycle
values restricted to {planned,pre-alpha,alpha,beta,stable,deprecated};
run_after/lifecycle never on a non-primary entity; empty run_after
lists rejected.
Also folded into this change set
* services_disabler now writes `services.<svc>.{enabled,shared}` into
host_vars instead of the old `compose.services.<svc>.{...}` path; the
discover/find pair walks meta/services.yml and only treats entries
carrying enabled/shared/provides as provider declarations (so
metadata-only entries from req-010 do not create spurious provider
rows).
* service_registry skips `run_after` deps whose target was filtered
out via SERVICES_DISABLED instead of failing the whole load.
* cli/mirror/resolver and cli/create/inventory/mirror_overrides emit/
consume the new applications.<role>.services.<svc>.image shape
(mirror.md updated to match).
* utils/domains/list.build_applications_from_roles now reads
meta/server.yml directly (it had been silently returning {} since
config/main.yml stopped existing).
* utils/roles/resource_validation.filter_roles_by_min_storage reads
meta/services.yml.<entity>.min_storage instead of the legacy
compose.services path.
* web-app-bluesky pre-clones the social-app build context BEFORE
sys-svc-compose so the build context is on disk by the time
sys-stk-front-proxy/tasks/main.yml flushes the docker build handler.
* 4 meta/variants.yml files (svc-ai-ollama, web-app-phpmyadmin,
web-app-wordpress, web-app-keycloak) lose their `compose: services:`
wrapper so deep-merge over meta/services.yml lands on the new
file-root shape.
Validation
* Unit tests: 1571 passed.
* Lint tests: 50 passed.
* Integration tests: 161 passed (1 skipped).
* Full-cycle fresh-purged-apps deploy succeeded for the 8-app validation
set: web-app-{nextcloud,wordpress,yourls,bigbluebutton,bluesky,gitea,
discourse,mattermost}.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Docker Official Image tags of the form `<semver>-<flavor>` (e.g. the
joomla:5.4.5-php8.3-apache pin) were previously skipped by the
`web-app` image version checker because its strict regex only matched
pure `x.y.z` shapes. As a result the auto-update workflow and the
external warning test never proposed a newer 5.4.x-php8.3-apache tag,
and flavored pins silently drifted out of date.
Widen the regex in `utils/docker/version_updater.py` to accept the
`<semver>-<flavor>` shape, with the flavor suffix treated as an opaque
discriminator: a candidate tag is only considered an upgrade when it
shares the *same* flavor. That guarantees a 5.4.5-php8.3-apache pin
never gets silently switched to 5.4.6-php8.4-apache or 5.4.6-fpm.
Refactor `tests/external/docker/test_image_versions.py` to import
directly from the util: ~130 lines of duplicated semver / Docker Hub /
GHCR helper code deleted, and the file now has exactly one code path
to keep in sync with the one used by the auto-update CLI
(`cli/fix/docker_image_versions`).
Chain impact:
* `.github/workflows/update.yml` -> `scripts/github/update_docker_image_versions.sh`
-> `python3 -m cli.fix.docker_image_versions` -> same util. No
workflow change needed; the next scheduled update run will pick
up flavored upgrades automatically.
* Live external run now reports 5 previously-silent upgrades:
web-app-joomla/joomla, web-app-magento/php, web-app-bridgy-fed,
web-app-suitecrm/php, web-app-shopware/redis.
Tests: existing `test_latest_semver_respects_depth` still covers the
pure-semver case; three new unit tests pin the flavor behaviour
(`is_semver` accepts flavored tags, `version_key/depth/flavor` strip
the flavor, `latest_semver` refuses cross-flavor upgrades).
Also drop an unused `autocreate_users: true` marker at the top of
`roles/web-app-joomla/config/main.yml` that was left over from an
earlier LDAP-autocreate experiment.
Keep new multi-registry logic (feature/pre-commit):
- Merge is_mirrorable_image(), _detect_registry(), image_source() and
canonical_image_name() into utils/docker/image_discovery.py
- iter_role_images() now scans both config/main.yml and vars/main.yml
and uses image_source() for full registry-prefixed URLs
- Delete cli/mirror/util.py (superseded by utils/docker/image_discovery)
- model.py re-exports ImageRef from utils.docker.image_discovery
- sync/__main__.py: revert fix/playwright-pull's if/else src URL to
simple `src = f"docker://{img.source}"` (source already contains
the full registry prefix)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Move iter_role_images + all helpers + ImageRef from cli/mirror/util.py and
cli/mirror/model.py into utils/docker/image_discovery.py; add source_file field
to ImageRef to distinguish config/main.yml vs vars/main.yml entries
- Delete cli/mirror/util.py; update all callers to import from utils.docker.image_discovery
- Move utils into subpackages: utils/docker/ (image_ref, paths_utils, hadolint) and
utils/roles/ (dependency_resolver, resource_validation); update all imports
- Reorganise tests into subpackages: tests/lint/docker/dockerfile/, tests/integration/docker/,
tests/unit/utils/docker/, tests/unit/utils/roles/; fix parents[N] offsets after relocation
- tests/lint/docker/test_image_versions.py now uses iter_role_images (same SPOT as mirror)
- Add vars/main.yml images.<name>.{image,version} support for non-application roles
(test-e2e-playwright, sys-ctl-hlth-csp); eliminate hardcoded duplicates in defaults/tasks
- Add web-app-matrix matrix-chatgpt-bot and web-app-mini-qr mini-qr entries in config/main.yml;
replace hardcoded image strings in vars/templates with lookup('config', ...) references
- Fix sync/__main__.py log line to use correct registry prefix for non-Docker-Hub images
- Update docs/contributing/code/role/dockerfile.md with image declaration rules and SPOT reference
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
kevinveenbirkenbach
Environment TestandClaude Sonnet 4.6